6 ms·
What does it mean that a leg broke? Correct me if I'm wrong cause I'm no expert, but I'd assume that there'd be some 'emergency' backup legs to address this kin
by heraclez 11y ago
What does it mean that a leg broke? Correct me if I'm wrong cause I'm no expert, but I'd assume that there'd be some 'emergency' backup legs to address this kind of event?
What does "not upright" mean? Did it crash? Or is it simply in limbo, leaning, at an x degree angle?
- atroyn 11y agoEvery extra part is extra weight, needing extra fuel, which in turn needs extra-extra-fuel because of the weight of that new fuel, and so on. There is very little redundancy on a rocket. It's unknown what exactly 'not upright' means just yet.
- heraclez 11y agoFair enough, how about some robotic arms on the drone ship ?
- atroyn 11y agoNow you have two problems. But I wonder if something much simpler, like a net, wouldn't make more sense. As soon as the rocket touches down, the net extents and wraps the rocket, keeping it upright.
- heraclez 11y agoWhat would be the two problems? How would you envision the net though? A net does sound simpler but I have a hard time picturing it
- atroyn 11y agoRobot arms are a complex control problem all on their own. To catch the rocket they'd have to be very fast, and very precise. At the same time, the rocket's control loops already have only a very small margin for error. A small miss by either system and you have a much higher chance of failure. In terms of a net, I imagine something that's lying on the deck under tension between four bendy rods. When the rocket is close enough, the rods snap over to the other side, furling the rocket in the net and holding it more or less steady.
- krschultz 11y agoI'm assuming that means it's in 10,000 pieces scattered across the Pacific. I'd be shocked if it didn't topple over, and once it goes over it's blowing up.
- Bjartr 11y ago> 'emergency' backup legs to address this kind of event? For the extra weight and complexity a second set of legs would add, I'd expect they'd shore up the primary legs instead, unless they were already at the threshold of being too heavy.
- Bjartr 11y ago> 'emergency' backup legs to address this kind of event? For the extra weight and complexity a second set of legs would add, I'd expect they'd shore up the primary legs instead, unless they were already at the threshold of being too heavy.