4 ms·
Press freedom is part of the German Grundgesetz (the constitution) as well, so there's really no difference here.
by luchs 11y ago
Press freedom is part of the German Grundgesetz (the constitution) as well, so there's really no difference here.
- eru 11y agoThe German Grundgesetz even puts all those basic rights right at the beginning and not just in the amendments.
- Aloha 11y agoThis strikes me as a weasel worded statement. The Bill of Rights was conceived along side the constitution and kept out of the original constitution largely for political reasons relating to getting a very contentious document approved by the required minimum number of states for passage.
- DasIch 11y agoWhat's important in particular about having those rights at the "beginning" of the Grundgesetz is that the first 20 articles are immutable and cannot be changed unlike the latter parts of the constitution.
- germanier 11y agoThis is not true. Only articles 1 and 20 can't be changed. For the rest in between no such guarantee applies and they were changed a few times in the past. Though most likely restricting any of the freedoms severely would be ruled unconstitutional by the very first article.
- eru 11y agoOf course, the constitution is just a piece of paper, and what's protecting the rights in practice is a political system (especially courts) that tries hard to keep them. Most of the rights already come pre-holed with exceptions, though. And lots of them contradict each other. There's lots of leeway, to justify a very wide range of policies as different `tradeoffs' between the rights.